Celtic Well
List RulesSubscribeE-JournalBook ReviewsFAQsContact
Read a Review
Submit Review
Author Guide
OOP FAQ
Reading List
Celtic Well> Book Reviews> Book Review Guidelines

The reviews you see on the Celtic Well site are written by people who have read the books and are seriously interested in Celtic culture in all its aspects. We would love to include your review, but please follow the guidelines listed below.

What to include:

  • 500 words maximum
  • Focus on the book's content and context
  • Specify what you do and do not like about the book
  • Be specific -- quotes with which you disagree are very welcome
  • Mention what types of readers will enjoy the book
  • Provide a valid e-mail address (it will not appear on the web site)
  • If you choose not to recommend the book, specify an alternative on the same subject, if possible
  • Comparisons with other books on the same or similar topic are welcome
  • Please spell-check your review before submitting it

What not to include:

  • Reviews for not-yet-released titles
  • Profanity, obscenities, or spiteful remarks
  • Marketing notices or other advertising material
  • One-word or single-sentence reviews
  • Author's phone numbers, mail addresses, URLs
  • Availability, price, or alternative ordering/shipping information

We would like to represent many different opinions. However, the editors of the site reserve the right not to post any review that we feel does not meet our standards.

List Rules | Subscribe | E-Journal | Book Reviews | FAQs | Contact